Project muse the resurgence of the latin american left. This thesis examines the emergence of the left in latin america at the turn of the century. By santiago anria and kenneth roberts after a long winning streak, the left in latin america has experienced electoral defeats in a number of former strongholds since 2015 including argentina, chile, and brazil but the trend is not unidirectional and so far falls short of being a regional right turn. With all the talk of latin america s turn to the left, few have noticed that there are really two lefts in the region.
Latin americas left turn 5 tended to be based on little more than a rejection of neoliberalism. Each and every period of its history is crucial in some way to understanding the presentday character of the land. Latin america s left turn mexicanborn political scientist jorge g. Brian cramer and robert kaufman, views of economic inequality in latin america, comparative political studies, 44. One has radical roots but is now openminded and modern. Latin america is swerving left,and distinct backlashes are under way against the predominant trends of the last 15 years. The longterm effects of the left turns, and their likely durabil ity, can only be a matter of debate. While histories of the other americas often link disparate histories through revolutionary or tragic narratives, latin america since independence begins with the assumption that our efforts to imagine a common past for nearly thirty countries are deeply problematic. The persistence of struggles by popular sectors in the context of the pink tide has generated ongoing debates about how to interpret the regions left turn. The south american revolutions the spread of revolution the latin american wars of independence, which took place during the late 18th and early 19th centuries, were deeply influenced by the american and french revolutions and resulted in the creation of a number of independent countries in latin america. Latin america since independence student resources. This volume examines the causes of this leftward turn and the consequences it carries for the region in the twentyfirst century.
Without losing sight of chronology or regional trends, this text offers glimpses of the latin. Latin america s left turn 5 tended to be based on little more than a rejection of neoliberalism. Kurt weyland, the performance of leftist governments in latin america. Clearly, the latin american left turn has not spawned a singular model of social and economic development that could be counterposed to that of neoliberalism. Latin is a classical language that profoundly influenced many other languages in the indoeuropean language family. Left, right, and wrong article pdf available in constellations 143. The south american revolutions boundless world history. One, embodied by the likes of michelle bachelet in chile and luis ignacio lula da silva in brazil, has radical roots but is now openminded and modern.
Latin americas left turns lynne rienner publishers. As the author argues, the case of venezuela is rather an excep. Lynne rienner publishers latin america s left turns. His research interests include political parties, authoritarianism and democratization, and weak and informal institutions, with a focus on latin america. Cbn news reporter, dale hurd, explains what latin america s left turn means for the usa. Eoin omalley may 2014 dissertation submitted for the award of phd to dublin city university dcu. Latin america since the left turn frames the tensions and contradictions that currently characterize latin american societies and politics in the early decades of the twentyfirst century, when many countries elected left wing governments in an attempt to reverse the neoliberal agenda while others continued and even extended it. As a term, both phrases are used in contemporary 21stcentury political analysis in the. I am particularly interested in features of latin american economies and labour markets that have con. In the political dimension, left wing parties and candidates rose to power in different countries, winning elections at.
Latin america is a group of countries and dependencies in the western hemisphere where romance languages such as spanish, portuguese, and french are predominantly spoken. The ultimate challenge for the left in latin america is to reconcile the substantive goals of inclusion and equality with the equally substantive goals of robust procedures and institutions. They, along with many other latin americans, would succeed in removing their rightwing governments who were nearly uniformly replaced with. Steven levitsky is professor of government at harvard university. The pendulum is starting to correct itself in many of these countries. Countries that maintained solid economic policies chile and colombia are prospering, while those that didnt are nearing economic failure. These were the calls of protestors in argentina attempting to oust their leaders in 2001 boidi, 2007, p. Part of the lefts challenge, therefore, is political. One form, most present in chile, uruguay and brazil, has marxist and castroist roots, but has evolved to a practice based in social policy and internationalism within a market framework. Published in 1993, the book explored what the end of the cold war meant for latin america s left. One form, most present in chile, uruguay and brazil, has marxist and castroist roots, but has evolved to a practice based in social policy and internationalism within a.
The emergence of populist leaders in latin america posed a unique paradigm for understanding the left in latin america during the cold war, since such leaders might be on the left or right side of the political spectrum, or some combination of the two. The combination of inequality and democracy tends to cause a movement to the left everywhere. S by devon haynie assistant managing editor, cities jan. The election of hugo chavez in 1998 in venezuela marked the start of what is now considered latin america s left turn or pink tide, in which eleven of the eighteen democratic countries elected left governments over the course of the next fifteen years. Latin america is generally understood to consist of the entire continent of south america in addition to mexico, central america, and the islands of the caribbean whose inhabitants speak a romance language. Pdf discontent and the left turn in latin america nina. However, with the several left turns observed since the end of the last century in latin america selligson 2007. Falleti and publisher university of pennsylvania press.
Left turn in latin america 2 with poor economic growth, macroeconomic instability, rising indigence and liberalization, together with unobserved heterogeneity can explain the vote intention of. The dilemma of the left in postneoliberal latin america thursday, september 19 steven levitsky and kenneth m. A left turn in latin america problems of success in chile. Retrospective voting in american national elections. Political trust in argentina and mexico, with susan c. The electoral success of the left across latin america has largely been interpreted as a backlash against globalization and a manifestation of antimarket voting of citizens increasingly frustrated with their experience of representative democracy. Castaneda describes the resurgence of leftidentified political leaders in latin america as twopronged. The struggle between commons and commodity approaches bakker, 2007 is only the beginning.
The peoples of this large area shared the experience of conquest and colonization by the. A recent publication by the brookings institution with recommendations for the obama administration on its policy towards latin america stressed that the united states should be involved in facilitating elections and strengthening parliament and political parties in haiti the obama administration and the americas 107. The book speaks to wideranging debates on democracy, the left, and citizenship in latin america. Latin america is swerving left, and distinct backlashes are under way against the predominant trends of the last 15 years. They, along with many other latin americans, would succeed in removing their rightwing governments who were nearly. The rise of the contemporary left in latin america. Influential publications such as foreign affairs and the economist, as well as a host of academic venues, have focused on latin americas current swing of. Discover the best way to learn latin, including the history of the latin language and how to get beyond latin translations.
Argentine peronism in comparative perspective 2003, co. Party system responsiveness and leftwing populist success in. The promise of inclusive citizenship contains original essays by a diverse group of leading and emerging scholars from north america, europe, and latin america. Dec 15, 20 the rise of the contemporary left in latin america.
Seligson l atin americas left turn was the focus of a cluster of thoughtful articles in the october 2006 issue of this journal. Since then, the trend toward the left and toward populist governments has deepened. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In steven levitsky and kenneth roberts, the resurgence of the latin american left, 1 30. Robinson argues with great analytical lucidity that latin americas current left turn, more than a manifestation of turbulence, is a struggle over the shape of the new world to come. Waning confidence in the region undermined economic development and the duration came to be known as the lost decade.
There are few, if any, works of synthesis that define the latin american new left as more than its armed wing. Latin americas turn to the left a tale of two lefts. Latin america s left turn about twothirds of all latin americans lived under some form of leftist government by 2010 a pink tide that washed over the region following the. The final, prescriptive pages solidified an earlyand controversialversion of.
A framework for analysis 1 steven levitsky and kenneth m. The ecuadorean and bolivian constitutions embraced the rights to nature, and atop machu. Unlike established historiographical fields in us or european history that associate the 1960s with a broadly defined new left, the term is more readily used for latin america to refer to the recent pink tide of democratically elected, left leaning governments. We address the puzzle of left governments and abortion policy reform during latin america s pink tide. Latin americas leftturn and the political empowerment of. The left turns legacies in the amazon eve bratman as leftist leadership gained political power in the early 2000s in latin america, environmental protectionand nature itselfbecame a more prominent regional political issue than ever before.
While some of the leftwing parties that came to govern in the post. Download citation latin americas left turn with all the talk of latin americas turn to the left, few have noticed that there are. Discontent and the left turn in latin america political. Latin america s pink tide or turn to the left has really given rise to two lefts. Economic policy and the regions relationship to the us and, by extension, to the middle east will continue to be a source of polarisation in latin america. The authors assess the multiple currents of latin america s left turns, considering their origins, their relationships to political parties and social movements, and their performance in office. Influential publications such as foreign affairs and the economist, as well as a host of academic venues, have focused on latin america s current swing of. Several analysts of the left turn indicate that this new latin american left is attempting to fundamentally move beyond the neoliberal framework to a postliberal society arditi, 2008arditi. For some, these movements are understood as forming part of a tense but ultimately productive. A history of united states policy towards haiti modern. Capitalmobility,vetoplayers,andredistributioninlatin. The political left, the export boom, and the populist temptation, in steve levitsky and kenneth m. Influential publications such as foreign affairs and the economist, as well as a host of academic venues, have focused on latin america s current swing of the pendulum. Pdf postcapitalist development in latin americas left.
While it is referred to as a dead language, latin is far from extinct. Posc 322 neoliberalism and the new left in latin america. Rather than fretting over the left s rise in general. Challenging more established assumptions of a left turn in latin america, fredrik ugglas article suggests that to speak of a general left turn might lead to a misinterpretation of latin american politics. Save up to 80% by choosing the etextbook option for isbn. It is broader than the terms ibero america or hispanic america in categorizing the new world.
Full of insider detail, its first 300 pages remain unequaled as a singlevolume study of the latin american left in the twentieth century. Introduction at the beginning of the twentyfirst century, left wing parties have won elections in various latin american countries. He is author of transforming laborbased parties in latin america. Jul 29, 2019 latin america has seen wars, dictators, famines, economic booms, foreign interventions, and a whole assortment of varied calamities over the years. Russell sage foundation, 2006 democracy and indigenous rebellion in latin america, comparative political studies 33. Divided into three sections, the book begins with an examination of the political economy, from models of development, to taxation and spending.
With all the talk of latin americas turn to the left, few have noticed that there are really two lefts in the region. The term comes from the fact that the predominant languages of the countries originated with the latin language. Politics, policies, and trajectories of change cameron, maxwell a. The washington consensus and latin americas left turn. The latin american left after the cold war, which made several points.
Seligson l atin america s left turn was the focus of a cluster of thoughtful articles in the october 2006 issue of this journal. The reasons for latin america s turn to the left are not hard to discern. Contributors to latin america since the left turn address these questions and more as they frame the tensions and contradictions that currently characterize latin american societies and politics. Will donald trump use it to the advantage of the u. Latin america, the united states, and the rise of the new imperialism.
Latin america s pink tide in part manifests itself in the succession of elec tions in which leftist presidential candidates have either won or performed nearly well enough to take office. The role of indigenous social movements in latin americas left turn. Rather, what i call the pragmatic turn of latin america s democratization consists in the attempt to correct some of the alleged failures of representative institutions with participatory and deliberative innovations. The politics of inequality and redistribution in latin america. Along with many other commentators and public intellectuals, i started detecting those reasons nearly fifteen years ago, and i recorded them in my book utopia unarmed. Latin american economic policies, latin america s extreme inequality latin america is the worlds most unequal r egion,poverty,and concentration of wealth, income, power, and opportunity meant that it would have to be governed from the left of center. These are the regions chronically poor, who have remained so despite unprecedented inroads against poverty in latin america and the caribbean since the turn of the century. The pendulum is starting to correct itself in many of these. Instead, it offers a diverse array of policy tools for tackling social problems of poverty and unemployment, some of which are compatible with neoliberal orthodoxy and others. Latin america enters the 20th century with social structures still in many ways characteristic of the colonial era. Latin america experienced an unprecedented wave of left leaning governments between 1998 and 2010. One, embodied by the likes of michelle bachelet in chile and luis ignacio lula da.
1120 992 1546 622 840 451 925 291 1253 1490 1213 209 87 371 1024 555 452 327 1228 290 1327 1274 754 917 425 1226 1464 1138 86 1151 1458 660 1016 319 1080 467 303 1453 767 1408 1476 114 362 253 186 36 418 509 828